Truth Be Told: My Journey Through Life and the Law

Truth Be Told: My Journey Through Life and the Law

by Beverley McLachlin

4.5/5
MemoirNon-Fiction ReviewBestseller

Published on October 29, 2025

Our Verdict

A graceful, deeply Canadian meditation on justice, integrity, and the human heart behind the law — a book that reminds us why moral authority must also be moral humility.

It’s rare for a jurist’s memoir to read like literature, rarer still for it to pulse with emotion. Truth Be Told — Beverley McLachlin’s candid, elegant account of her journey from a small Alberta town to becoming Canada’s first female Chief Justice of the Supreme Court — manages both. This is not just the story of a legal mind at work, but of a life defined by conscience, curiosity, and quiet courage. McLachlin writes with the precision one might expect from a jurist, but also with the warmth of someone who has learned to look beyond the bench. Her early chapters paint a vivid portrait of a rural childhood shaped by hardship, faith, and intellectual hunger. She reflects on her years as a law professor, lawyer, and judge with an admirable humility — acknowledging the privileges that carried her forward, but also the self-doubt that trailed behind. What elevates Truth Be Told above the standard judicial memoir is McLachlin’s willingness to explore vulnerability. She writes openly about personal loss — the death of her first husband, the challenges of single motherhood, the loneliness of public life — without ever slipping into sentimentality. Her honesty, especially about moments of uncertainty and moral conflict, gives the book its heart. The judicial sections are surprisingly accessible. McLachlin guides readers through some of Canada’s defining constitutional and ethical debates — from freedom of expression to Indigenous rights and physician-assisted dying — with a clarity that never condescends. She brings the reader inside the intellectual tension of the courtroom, where human consequences hang on finely balanced interpretations of law. Yet even here, she reminds us that the law is never just abstract principle; it is a living conversation about who we are as a nation. Stylistically, her prose is graceful and uncluttered. She writes as she likely spoke from the bench: measured, thoughtful, firm in logic but generous in tone. The book’s greatest strength is its balance — part memoir, part meditation, part gentle call to civic reflection. If there is a flaw, it lies in her restraint. Readers seeking fiery political commentary or judicial gossip will not find it here. McLachlin’s integrity, which has defined her career, also defines her writing — she offers insight, not scandal; introspection, not indulgence. Ultimately, Truth Be Told is less about one woman’s ascent than about the responsibilities of power and the humanity that must ground it. It reminds us that the law, at its best, is an act of storytelling — an attempt to give meaning and fairness to the messy realities of life.

Back to All Reviews
Share this review: